Click for menu
Member for Chisholm and former speaker of the House Anna Burke
Anna Burke MP was first elected as the representative for Chisholm at the 1998 Federal Election. She was re-elected at the 2001 Federal Election and at the October 9th 2004 Federal Election. She quit politics at the end of 2016. Image: Thanks to M. Fairclough and Fairfax

ALP Member for Chisholm Anna Burke contradicts refugee policy

Anna Burke MP was first elected as the representative for Chisholm at the 1998 Federal Election. She was re-elected at the 2001 Federal Election and at the October 9th 2004 Federal Election.

MP contradicts refugee policy

The Australian
Elizabeth Colman
September 29, 2004

FEDERAL Labor backbencher Anna Burke has contradicted her party's policies on refugees, saying that asylum-seekers should be released from immigration detention after health checks.

Breaking from Labor's policy of mandatory detention, Ms Burke, who holds the marginal Victorian seat of Chisholm, also said that asylum-seekers should be entitled to work in the community and to receive Medicare, while awaiting the outcome of their claim for refugee status.

Ms Burke's surprising statements were contained in answers to a survey of 35 federal electorates, including 27 marginal seats, by refugee advocacy group The Justice Project led by prominent Melbourne barrister Julian Burnside QC.

Ms Burke said she "agreed" with a range of statements, including that "asylum-seekers should be held in detention until health and security checks are completed". She did not return calls from The Australian last night.

Chisholm in Melbourne's eastern suburbs is largely made up of immigrants and people aged over 60. It is held by a margin of 2.7 per cent.

Labor's candidate for the neighbouring Liberal marginal seat of Deakin, former Labor for Refugees figure Peter Lynch, also broke party ranks on mandatory detention. But most ALP members declined to participate.

Labor's immigration spokesman Stephen Smith on Monday declined to respond to Attorney-General Philip Ruddock's stinging attack on Labor's policy.

Mr Ruddock accused Labor of winding back measures implemented by the Howard Government to stop boat arrivals, and described the Opposition's mandatory detention policy as "weak".

A spokeswoman for Mr Smith yesterday ruled out buying into the debate. "We're not going to comment on the immigration element", she said. "We just don't want to react to it".

Only one Liberal responded to the questionnaire.

Mr Burnside said last night both the Coalition and Labor were "now quietly embarrassed about their own policies".

"If you ask ordinary Australians whether they think its all right to send people back to torture or lock up children they will say no," he said.

It is understood only one Liberal candidate, Steve Gibbons for Labor-held Bendigo, responded to the questionnaire.,5744,10913979%255E2702,00.html

Labor MP defends mandatory detention

Green Left Weekly
October 27 2004
Zoe Kenny, Melbourne

October 19, 40 people attended a public forum at the Victorian Trades Hall organised by the Refugee Action Collective (RAC) to discuss perspectives for the refugee-rights movement after the re-election of the Coalition government.

Ahmed Raza, an Afghan temporary protection visa holder, spoke of his worry that he may not be allowed to stay in Australia, now that the Howard government has been re-elected. RAC activist Sandra Bloodworth pointed out that parliament is not the decisive factor in achieving progressive change and emphasised the importance of grassroots movements on the streets.

Federal Labor MP Anna Burke, who has been thanked by the refugee-rights movement in the past for breaking ranks with ALP policy on the issue of refugees, raised the ire of many at the forum when she spoke of the need to maintain mandatory detention of refugees as a means of curbing the spread of "communicable diseases".